Bethany Homes for Sale

Welcome to Bethany, Connecticut – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of New Haven County. Known for its picturesque landscapes and tight-knit community, Bethany offers a tranquil retreat from the hustle and bustle of city life while still being conveniently located just a short drive from New Haven and other urban amenities. With its rolling hills, lush greenery, and charming rural vibe, this town is perfect for those seeking a peaceful lifestyle without sacrificing accessibility.

Bethany boasts a rich history, with roots dating back to the 18th century, and its scenic beauty is complemented by a variety of recreational opportunities. Residents enjoy access to numerous parks, hiking trails, and outdoor activities, making it an ideal locale for nature enthusiasts and families alike. The town also prides itself on its excellent school system and community events, fostering a warm and welcoming atmosphere.

For those considering a move to this idyllic setting, there are a variety of homes for sale that cater to diverse tastes and lifestyles. From charming colonial-style houses to modern developments, you’ll find properties that reflect the unique character of Bethany. Whether you're searching for a cozy starter home, a spacious family residence, or a serene retreat, the real estate market here offers something for everyone.

Explore the wonderful homes available in Bethany today, and discover how this enchanting town can be the perfect backdrop for your next chapter! Embrace the opportunity to become part of this vibrant community and enjoy all that Bethany has to offer.

Newest Bethany Homes for Sale

$599,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 24191021 MLS

Welcome to this spacious 4-bedroom, 3 full-bath home nestled in one of Bethany's most beloved neighborhood streets. Located on Woodcutters Drive, this welcoming community has an old-fashioned feel, where neighbors know each other by name and you'll feel right at home from the moment you arrive. Inside, you'll find a bright, open-concept layout designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The expansive family room and dining area flow seamlessly together, creating the perfect gathering space for holidays, celebrations, or relaxing evenings at home around the new pellet stove. New luxury vinyl flooring throughout the main level adds a fresh, modern touch while providing durability and style. Upstairs, the private primary suite offers a peaceful retreat featuring a spacious dressing room/walk-in closet and an attached full bathroom. The home's 3 additional bedrooms and 2 more full bathrooms provide plenty of room for family, guests, or a home office. The partially finished basement offers flexible living space, ideal for a recreation room, home gym, playroom, or media room. Outside, the above-ground pool is ready for endless summer fun, making the yard the perfect place to unwind or entertain. Set in the heart of Bethany, you'll enjoy the town's rural charm, scenic beauty, and close-knit community while still being conveniently located near shopping, dining, and major commuting routes. This is more than just a house-it's a place to call home.

67 Woodcutters Dr, Bethany

$980,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 24179361 MLS

Tucked away on a quiet, wooded cul-de-sac, this Colonial offers over 4,000 square feet of beautifully designed living space where soaring ceilings, skylights, and abundant natural light create an open, inviting atmosphere from the moment you step inside. A dramatic two-story foyer with marble floors sets the tone, leading to spacious living areas that are equally suited for everyday living and effortless entertaining. Designed with flexibility in mind, the home offers generously sized bedrooms with cathedral and vaulted ceilings, along with a finished room above the garage complete with its own full bathroom and separate interior entrance. Whether used as a guest suite, space for extended family, a home office, or a recreation room, it offers the versatility today's homeowners are looking for. Step outside to enjoy the privacy of the wooded backyard, where a paved basketball court and ample play space create the perfect setting for recreation, gatherings, and making lasting memories. Ideally located with convenient access to New Haven, Waterbury, and major commuter routes, this exceptional home combines space, privacy, and flexibility in one of Bethany's most desirable settings. This is a home that truly needs to be experienced in person.

35 Judd Hill Rd, Bethany

$599,900

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 24187176 MLS

Welcome to 45 Carmel Rd. Tucked into the peaceful hills of Bethany, this enchanting Colonial offers the perfect blend of timeless charm, privacy, and modern comfort. Set on more than 5 lightly wooded acres with a sprawling open field, this property feels like your own private getaway while remaining conveniently close to local amenities. A classic wraparound porch welcomes you home, providing the perfect spot to enjoy your morning coffee or unwind while taking in the tranquil surroundings. Inside, soaring 9-foot ceilings and a warm country-style kitchen create an inviting atmosphere that's ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. Offering over 3,100 square feet of living space, the home features three spacious bedrooms, two and a half baths, and a thoughtfully designed layout that balances openness with cozy gathering spaces. A charming fireplace anchors the main living area, while the finished room above the garage and an additional room provide exceptional flexibility for a home office, guest suite, or recreation room. The third-floor playroom adds even more versatility, making it the perfect space for a playroom, studio, media room, or peaceful getaway. Step outside and immerse yourself in nature. Surrounded by serene woodlands and located just moments from local horse trails, this property invites you to embrace a slower pace of life.

45 Carmel Rd, Bethany

$675,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 24186286 MLS

Nestled on a private 5-acre setting in the Amity School District, this exceptional contemporary home offers the perfect blend of privacy, character, & comfort. Set high atop a hill and tucked well back from the road, the property provides a peaceful retreat surrounded by nature. Boasting 3,396 square feet of living space, this move-in ready home is filled with distinctive architectural details, soaring ceilings, and expansive windows that bring the beauty of the outdoors inside. The spacious living room features hardwood flooring, a fireplace, and a dramatic loft above connected by a bridge overlook. A separate den also offers hardwood floors and its own fireplace, creating warm and inviting living spaces. The modern chef's kitchen is equipped with granite countertops, ample cabinetry and generous workspace for cooking and entertaining. The main level includes an in-law bedroom or guest suite, offering flexibility for extended family, guests, or multi-generational living. Upstairs the primary suite serves as a private sanctuary with floor-to-ceiling windows overlooking the natural surroundings a beautifully appointed primary bath, and a unique exercise loft. Two additional bedrooms complete the upper level. Surrounded by mature trees and set in a tranquil hillside location, this one of a kind contemporary home offers exceptional privacy, abundant natural light, and a seamless connection to nature while remaining within the highly regarded Amity School District.

151 Cheshire Rd, Bethany

$779,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 24185652 MLS

At the end of a winding drive, tucked within 4.56 acres of peaceful woodland, sits a home that feels as though it was lifted from the pages of a storybook. Welcome to 285 Wooding Hill Road - a place where nature, craftsmanship, and quiet beauty come together in a way that is both rare and unforgettable. From the moment you arrive, the world seems to slow. The gentle sound of the brook, the rustle of trees, every inch of this property invites you to breathe deeper, stay longer, and savor the simple beauty of home. Inside, the home is rich with warmth, texture, and timeless character. Hand-hewn beams, wide plank floors, and artisan details tell a story of thoughtful design and enduring craftsmanship. The gorgeous kitchen was renovated top to bottom in 2019. At the heart of it all is a truly unforgettable gathering space featuring a custom bar, with a wood-fired pizza oven, built from materials found right on the property - a one-of-a-kind centerpiece that brings friends and family together. The outdoor detached barn can be transferred into anything you need- suitable for workshop, or horses/ animals with a wood stove. 2019 upgrades -New septic, well pump, roof on main home, detached barn and garage. Electrical upgrades with additional sub panel. 2019 remodeled kitchen top to bottom with natural edge granite counter. Outdoor kitchen and barn both have hot and cold water. A home that offers a lifestyle rooted in comfort, charm, and serenity. MOTIVATED SELLERS

285 Wooding Hill Rd, Bethany

$440,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 24185584 MLS

A gardener's paradise, this inviting ranch-style retreat sits at the private end of a cul de sac on a 1.1 acre lot, surrounded by gorgeous, mature gardens bursting with peonies, foxglove, cranesbill, bleeding hearts, daffodils, and flowering shrubs. Inside, the flexible floor plan features a dining room (currently used as a living room) with a pass through fireplace to the main living room and a bay window that floods the space with natural light. Hardwood floors run through most of the main level, while the living room offers a second fireplace and sliders leading to a spacious entertaining deck overlooking the grounds. Remodeled kitchen with custom-made Hickory cabinets, Corian counters and stainless steel appliances. The home includes 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and 1 half bath, fist floor laundry with storage and walk-in Cedar closet, plus a finished walkout level family room with luxury vinyl flooring, offering possible in-law/multi-generational space. Major updates-newer well, water holding tank, oil tank, septic tank, A/C & heat pump, hot water heater, and roof-provide peace of mind. A 2 car garage with workbench completes this beautifully maintained property, perfect for anyone who loves nature, privacy, and comfortable single level living. ASSURANT HOME PROTECTION PLAN! Pre-approved Buyers Only

25 Mountain View Rd, Bethany

$699,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 24184629 MLS

A Bethany hidden gem, this renovated and expanded farmhouse sits on a private 1.5 acre parcel at the end of a quiet cul de sac and is being offered for sale for the first time by the longtime family who cherished it. The spacious 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home features a wonderful open floor plan ideal for both indoor and outdoor entertaining. Renovated and expanded in 2006, the first floor offers exceptional versatility with a family room, living room, dining room and a flexible home office option. Upstairs, the generous primary suite includes abundant closet space and a full bath, complemented by three additional well sized bedrooms, a hall bath, and convenient second floor laundry. Outside, the property transforms into a private retreat with an inground pool, wrap around open porch, deck, screened porch, and an expansive patio surrounding the pool. A detached two car garage includes a second floor loft perfect for exercise equipment, creative space, or a home office. Additional highlights include Thermal Andersen windows, central air conditioning, a portable generator hookup, and a security system. Located within an award winning school system and offering easy access to Yale, downtown New Haven, Route 15, Route 8, and shopping, this home blends charm, comfort, and convenience in a truly special setting.

57 Edwards Rd, Bethany

$1,625,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 24179706 MLS

Imagine waking up, stepping outside, saddling your horse, and riding directly from your own property onto miles of scenic trails. That dream has an address! Nestled on one of Bethany's most sought-after roads, Sperry road is prized for its privacy, convenience, and idyllic setting for a peaceful country retreat. Set on 7.3 private, level acres, this stunning 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath home embodies timeless New England elegance blending classic charm with refined country sophistication. A welcoming front porch stretches across the front of the home, inviting you to relax and take in the peaceful surroundings. The home's distinctive architecture showcases beautiful dormer rooflines, multiple fireplaces, Palladian windows, transoms, and a cupola-topped garage, creating character and curb appeal at every turn. Sunlight pours through the expansive windows, filling the home with warmth while framing the breathtaking views. Complete privacy both on the front and rear of the property, offering a serene backdrop for everyday living. The expansive ground offers endless possibilities for equestrian pursuits, gardening or simply enjoying the beauty of nature. Equestrian amenities include a beautifully finished 36x36 horse barn complete with 4 stalls and a tack room, making this truly exceptional horse property. A stunning home, a beautiful barn, and acres to roam- this is more than a property, it's a lifestyle. Home is where the horses are!

395 Sperry Rd, Bethany

$425,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 24179042 MLS

Enjoy one level living in this large ranch style home offering 2,268 sq. ft. in Bethany. Spacious kitchen with brick wall. Living room/Dining room with fireplace. There are 3 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, first floor family room with fireplace. Also, an office or guest room, large unfinished basement and 2-car attached garage. This home sits on a beautiful level 1.7-acre parcel. Property abuts the SaddleView, a working horse farm that offers boarding horses and hosts events. Home has new furnace and A/C (2/25) and features a new roof (8/22). Don't miss this opportunity to own a property with great space, potential and charm!

186 Schaeffer Rd, Bethany

$479,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 24179002 MLS

"Welcome Home to 37 Anella Drive, Bethany-Experience true one-level living in this charming home, lovingly maintained by the same family for nearly 60 years. Offering over 2,000 sq/ft.- 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, this property combines comfort, functionality, and a peaceful setting. The spacious dining room is perfect for hosting family and friends, while the large living room features a beautiful stone fireplace with a pellet stove, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The primary bedroom suite is a private retreat, complete with skylights and its own full bathroom. Most of the main level features hardwood flooring, with durable tile flooring in the Eat-in kitchen. The walkout lower level provides additional flexible living space, ideal for a family room, home office, recreation area, or guest space. Step outside to enjoy the large deck, perfect for entertaining or relaxing while taking in the tranquil surroundings. Mature trees and private woods create a scenic, rural setting with ample privacy on this 1.1-acre property. 2-car garage and dedicated workshop area. Another nice feature is a Whole House Generator. Expansive driveway with turnaround and abundant off-street parking. Convenient access to Routes 63, 69, and 42 for easy commuting. This is a great opportunity to own a well-maintained home in Bethany, with a strong school system, privacy, and convenience."

37 Anella Dr, Bethany

$605,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 24176187 MLS

Don't miss out on this secluded rear lot Colonial located in the heart of Bethany! An expansive 4 Bedroom home, offering a lifestyle of leisure & enjoyment at this tranquil 3.63 acre tree-lined property. As you travel down the private freshly milled driveway you soon get a glimpse of the home set far back from the road. Walk across the cobblestone pathway, onto the welcoming porch entrance as you begin your tour of the inside. Newly refinished hardwood floors bring you through the L-Shaped combo Living room/Dining room complete w/wood burning Fireplace & bay window overlooking a tree-filled yard. Directly off the Living room we enter a bright & welcoming Eat-in-Kitchen once again w/hardwood floors, white cabinets, SS appliances & dining space. Rounding out the main level is a generous Family room w/vinyl flooring & 2nd Fireplace w/electric insert & sliders leading to the enjoyable private back deck. Upstairs we find new vinyl flooring covering the entire top level. At one end of the home the primary suite awaits, offering a walk-in closet, Full bath (w/room for expansion) & extra room over garage offering options for more closet space or possible small office! 3 more Bedrooms & hallway Full Bath tie the upper level all together. The home also features a full unfinished basement just waiting to be completed into additional living space, along with oversized 2 Car Garage, New Roof/Solar PPA, Newer CA. *PICTURES WERE TAKEN BEFORE SELLERS MOVED OUT & B4 UPSTAIRS FLOORS WERE DONE

225 Bethmour Rd, Bethany

$1,599,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 24171466 MLS

A home that feels like a getaway, every single day! Discover unparalleled privacy in this exceptional contemporary ranch, situated on nearly 3 acres at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac. Built within the last 5 years, this custom estate overlooks a tranquil pond and showcases elite craftsmanship. The interior features imported European windows and doors, designer European imported ceramic tile, showers feature protective film on the glass and premium finishes throughout. The open-concept floor plan is anchored by a bespoke chef's kitchen with custom cabinetry and high grade granite counters. The residence offers expansive living spaces and a functional laundry suite with abundant built-in storage. Retreat to spa-inspired bathrooms featuring heated floors, exquisite European tilework, and seamless hidden drain systems. A finished attic provides flexible bonus space, perfect for a home office, gym, or studio. Engineered for peak efficiency, the home includes propane heating and enhanced spray foam insulation. The exterior is an entertainer's dream, featuring a covered patio, level private grounds, and peaceful water views. A standout feature is the finished outbuilding, complete with electricity and a cozy fireplace-offering a luxurious extension for a creative workspace or lounge. Square footage includes finished attic rooms. This one-of-a-kind residence blends modern high-end luxury with a serene, natural setting. If you've been waiting for something different... this is it.

99 Mesa Dr, Bethany

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website appears in part through the SMARTMLS Internet Data Exchange program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms, and is provided by SMARTMLS through a licensing agreement. Listing information is from various brokers who participate in the SMARTMLS IDX program and not all listings may be visible on the site. The property information being provided on or through the website is for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers and such information may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Some properties which appear for sale on the website may no longer be available because they are for instance, under contract, sold or are no longer being offered for sale. Property information displayed is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. Copyright 2026 SmartMLS, Inc.